March 30, 2017

Guide to Top Memory Foam Mattress Brands

Guide to Top Memory Foam Mattress Brands

Consumers in the market for a top quality memory foam mattress may be stumped about which of the leading memory foam mattress brands is the best choice for their lifestyle. There are a number of aspects that go along with each brand that shoppers should weigh carefully in order to ensure that the mattress that they purchase is, in fact, the one that is most suited for them.  Here, we will discuss the various components of the leading brands and what sets each brand apart from the rest to help you feel more knowledgeable and prepared to make the right choice for your lifestyle.

Top Three Memory Foam Mattress Brands

Our comparison looks at three leading brands of memory foam: Tempurpedic, Serta iComfort, and Amerisleep. Why only these three? Currently these brands represent the three major categories of memory foam and the leading names of their type. There are many other brands out there, but we selected these based on a few factors like longevity, popularity, and availability. In the following write-up, we will offer background information, details about each product line, and offer an introduction to the features of each.

Traditional Memory Foam Mattress Brand: Tempurpedic

Tempurpedic is one of the most popular and well-advertised memory foam mattress brands in the market, and many other memory foam mattresses are compared to it. Most consumers report keeping their Tempurpedic mattress for at least ten years which is considerably longer than the average 5-7 years. The bed is known for providing  comfort and support with limited reports of sagging especially in the firmer models.

However, this mattress does have a few downfalls. One is that Tempurpedic mattresses are generally 20-50% more expensive than comparable mattresses. There are also indications that the mattress produces strong off-gassing due to the chemical makeup of the mattress, which proves to be an issue for about 15% of people. Another disadvantage is that the mattress is known for retaining heat more than other similar mattresses, due it slow-response, high-conforming nature.

Recently the brand has been shaking things up with the Breeze line (cooler covers), Cloud & Weightless lines (softer, less dense foam), and Simplicity (aiming at lower prices with low density foam).

  • Lifespan: Above Average
  • Price Range: $699-8499
  • Warranty: 25 years (10 years full)
  • Off Gassing: Yes, likely contains VOCs
  • Heat: Yes, reports of heat retention
  • Foam Density: 2.5-5.3lb

Gel Memory Foam Mattress Brand: Serta iComfort

Serta, long known for innerspring mattresses, recently added the iComfort line which offers gel-infused memory foam beds.There are a number of things that consumers like about iComfort memory foam mattresses. The bed stays true to typical memory foam attributes such as motion isolation, pain relief and proper comfort. However, unlike traditional memory foam, iComfort beds have fewer reports of off-gassing or heat retention.

The bad reports involve complaints that the dimensions are smaller than expected and that there are some issues with the bed being uniform throughout (i.e. sagging and lumpiness). Because the mattress is still fairly new to the market, not much is known currently about how well iComfort holds up throughout the years, and some sources have presented concerns about gel in the long-term.

Another important aspect to mention is that one of the biggest claims made by iComfort and other gel foams is that they sleep cooler. However, recent studies from Tempurpedic showed a slight advantage, sparking the National Advertising Board to request that Serta quit making direct comparison claims. Consumer Reports 2013 guide also mentioned no discernible difference in breathability with gel mattresses. Plant-based memory foam manufacturer Cargill found plant-based foams to sleep 25% cooler than gel as well.

  • Lifespan: Average to Above Average (somewhat unknown)
  • Price Range: $1299-2999
  • Warranty: 25 year warranty (15 years full)
  • Off Gassing: Yes, likely contains VOCs
  • Heat: Yes, reports of heat retention
  • Foam Density: 3.0-5.0lb

Plant Based Memory Foam Mattress Brand: Amerisleep

Amerisleep memory foam mattresses offer a different approach, relying on plant-based materials and taking a more eco-friendly model. This brand attracts consumers that like the feel of memory foam, but maybe have sensitivities toward chemicals. For those that are concerned about their environmental impact, the materials utilize sustainable resources and the memory foam is manufactured using a zero emissions process.

Plant-based memory foam offers an inherently more open-celled and responsive structure. This means that the material is more breathable, and conforms more readily to sleepers. This prevents the issues with the standard types like sleeping hot, or feeling stuck in bed. Consumer reviews report good durability and comfort, receiving high than average marks in the website’s third-party verified reviews. A few consumers found their bed to be firmer than they expected, but this was the only negative mentioned.

Prices are considerably lower for comparative models, likely owing to savings of selling direct to consumers via an online model, versus a dealer network. Amerisleep also offers a larger selection of well-rated adjustable bases at lower prices than Tempurpedic.

  • Lifespan: Above Average
  • Price Range: $649-2199
  • Warranty: 20 years (10 years full)
  • Off Gassing: No VOCs
  • Heat: No reports of heat retention in nearly 200 reviews
  • Foam Density: 4.0-5.3lb


There are a number of memory foam mattress brands to choose from and it may be difficult to distinguish which may be the best for you. However, once you read over the pros and cons of the mattresses above you may have a better understanding of which one you would be more interested in. They all possess the typical memory foam attributes such as comfort, support, and durability. Where Tempurpedic is the standby luxury brand, iComfort touts cooling gel, and Amerisleep claims cooler, more responsive, and healthier mattresses. Consumers should reflect on the information provided about the memory foam mattress brands and the products they offer, and choose the mattress that would best suit their lifestyle and concept of value.

Article Tags

Related Posts